Before You Sign: A Homeowner's Checklist for Hiring Tree Contractors
Tree work looks simple from the pavement. A bloke, a chainsaw, a rope. In practice it is one of the riskiest jobs in domestic property — for the climber, for your roof, and for the tree itself. And unlike gas fitting, there is no single legal gatekeeper stopping an unqualified person from advertising 'tree surgery' on a van. So the vetting is down to you.
Start with paperwork, not the price
Cheapest quote is not the same as best value. Before you compare numbers, ask for three documents: public liability insurance (usually at least £5 million, £10 million on larger domestic contracts), employers' liability insurance if anyone is on the payroll, and a waste carrier licence. In England, check the waste carrier registration with the Environment Agency; in Wales it is Natural Resources Wales; in Scotland, SEPA. Ask for the registration number and verify it. A firm that cannot produce these is not a firm you want in your garden.
Qualifications that actually mean something
'Fully qualified' is a phrase, not a certificate. Real, checkable qualifications include NPTC or City & Guilds chainsaw units, Lantra awards, and the ISA Certified Arborist credential. Membership of the Arboricultural Association — especially Approved Contractor status — is a useful filter. Ask who will actually be climbing and what tickets they hold. The person quoting is not always the person with the harness.
The written specification is the quote
A proper quote is a specification, not a scribbled figure. It should name the species, the number of trees, approximate height and spread, and exactly what is being removed. 'Crown thin by 15 per cent', 'crown reduce to 5 metres', 'remove deadwood over 50mm', 'fell to ground level and grind stump to 200mm below grade' — that is the language you want. Check whether waste removal is included, whether the lawn and borders will be protected, and whether VAT is on top. A price with no written scope is an argument waiting to happen.
References, addresses and a look at Companies House
Ask for two or three recent local references and actually ring them. Ask for the company's registered address and company number, then check Companies House. A mobile number and a first name is not a business identity. Reviews are helpful but easy to game; a reference from a street you know is better.
Red flags to walk away from
- A knock on the door after a storm, offering to 'tidy up' because they are 'working nearby'.
- Cash only, no receipt, no address.
- Pressure to sign today because the price will double tomorrow.
- A recommendation to 'top' or 'lop' a tree. Topping creates weak regrowth and lasting damage.
- No insurance certificate, or a certificate that names a different company.
- No waste carrier licence, or a promise to 'tip it at a mate's farm'.
- A deposit demand of 50 per cent before any work starts. A modest booking deposit is normal; a large upfront payment is not.
- Refusal to put the specification in writing.
What a fair quote should include
Expect the quote to cover labour, equipment, insurance, waste disposal, and travel. Stump grinding is often extra — ask. If the tree is protected by a Tree Preservation Order or sits in a conservation area, a good contractor will flag it and may handle the application. If they shrug at that question, worry.
Get two or three quotes and compare like for like, not just the bottom line. The cheapest quote often leaves something out: the waste, the stump, the insurance, the VAT. A slightly higher quote with a clear specification is usually the cheaper job in the long run.
A genuine tree surgeon will welcome questions about tickets, insurance and method. A cowboy will get prickly and talk about trust. Trust is earned with paperwork.